{"id":506172,"date":"2021-02-11T18:23:07","date_gmt":"2021-02-11T18:23:07","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/glaad.logalt.net\/tap\/abigail-shrier\/"},"modified":"2023-04-21T22:29:41","modified_gmt":"2023-04-21T22:29:41","slug":"abigail-shrier","status":"publish","type":"gap","link":"https:\/\/glaad.org\/gap\/abigail-shrier\/","title":{"rendered":"Abigail Shrier"},"content":{"rendered":"

\u2014Appeared<\/a> at a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on the Equality Act, raising hypothetical questions about transgender women: \u201cIf a preschool has a policy that only female teachers may accompany little girls to the bathroom, and your daughter\u2019s male teacher suddenly identifies as female, ought that teacher have a legal entitlement to accompany her? Does that strike anyone in this room as sensible or safe? Should a female abuse survivor at a domestic violence shelter be forced to sleep and undress next to a biological male?\u201d Trans women have been accommodated at federally-funded shelters<\/a> for the last eight years with no evidence of being a threat to cisgender residents. 70% of transgender shelter residents have reported physical violence, harassment, or forced removal because of their gender identity. 23% of transgender people experienced housing discrimination<\/a> such as being evicted or denied a home because of their gender identity. Trans women are not \u201cbiologically male;\u201d scientific research demonstrates that sex is not binary<\/a> even without considering transition-related medical care.<\/p>\n

\u2014At the Senate hearing<\/a>, raised an unproven claim about an assault in Washington state as a reason to reject the Equality Act. Shrier said: \u201cJust last week, after the Washington Correctional Center for Women began housing prisoners according to gender identity, half a dozen men transferred to the women\u2019s prison. One of the inmates raped a female in the women\u2019s prison upon arrival. If you pass this bill, you can expect hundreds more victims like this one\u2014and that has nothing to do with transgender people and everything to do with opportunistic self-identification by violent male felons.\u201d The claim about inmate rape was made anonymously<\/a> and has not been confirmed by the corrections department that it happened or is being investigated. Reporting<\/a> shows 15 of nearly 5,000 transgender inmates are housed according to their gender identity. 35% of trans prisoners report being sexually assaulted, according to the Department of Justice<\/a>. <\/p>\n

\u2014Repeatedly misrepresented<\/a> transgender sports participation: \u201cShould [a cisgender girl] lose her college scholarship to a male-bodied athlete who might never have qualified for the boys\u2019 team?\u201d Claimed: \u201cI have probably interviewed more transgender Americans than any person in this room. And I can honestly say that, excepting political activists, most do not want to obliterate women\u2019s rights and protective spaces. Most would never think of stealing women\u2019s scholarships, by forcing young women into demoralizing contests with male bodies.\u201d There have been no instances of a transgender athlete getting a scholarship, and trans athletes have been participating in sports for years with no evidence of dominating or demoralizing contests. A cisgender athlete who filed a lawsuit, with the help of the anti-LGBTQ legal group ADF, defeated<\/a> one of the transgender athletes named in the lawsuit for the Connecticut state championship two days after filing the suit.<\/p>\n

\t\u2014Stated that trans youth are \u201cinspired\u201d<\/a> to be trans based on what their friends are doing. There is no scientific evidence that this happens, and a researcher’s report on the alleged phenomenon was pulled and republished with a correction<\/a> reading in part: \u201cRapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) is not a formal mental health diagnosis at this time. This report did not collect data from the adolescents and young adults (AYAs) or clinicians and therefore does not validate the phenomenon. Additional research that includes AYAs, along with consensus among experts in the field, will be needed to determine if what is described here as rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) will become a formal diagnosis. Furthermore, the use of the term, rapid-onset gender dysphoria should be used cautiously by clinicians and parents to describe youth who appear to fall into this category. The term should not be used in a way to imply that it explains the experiences of all gender dysphoric youth nor should it be used to stigmatize vulnerable individuals.\u201d As researcher Dr. Jack Turban notes<\/a>, \u201cUnfortunately, the paper did not survey any of the youth themselves or their clinicians. The only thing the paper established is that some people online believe that youth rapidly become transgender as a result of watching trans-related content on Youtube and Reddit.\u201d<\/p>\n

\u2014Claims<\/a> increased transgender identity among teens is an expression of undiagnosed mental health disturbance: \u201cIf we\u2019re just reverting to normal now that there\u2019s greater societal acceptance\u2014right, say we\u2019re just reverting to a normal base rate of transgender women\u2014where are all the women in their 40s and 60s coming out as trans? They should be coming out. Now\u2019s their time. Now\u2019s their moment. We should see tons of women in their 40s and 60s and so on coming out as transgender. We\u2019re not seeing that. We\u2019re seeing the same population that gets involved in cutting, demonic possession, witchcraft, anorexia, bulimia, and convinces themselves there\u2019s a problem.\u201d In her column in the Wall Street Journal, discussing her book on the \u201ctransgender craze,\u201d Shrier writes: \u201cI think mature adults should have the freedom to undergo medical transition. But teenagers are another matter. Social contagions exist, and teen girls are particularly susceptible to them. The book takes a hard look at whether the sudden spike in transgender identification among teen girls is yet another social contagion to befall girls who, in another era, might have fallen prey to anorexia or bulimia.\u201d Population data<\/a> shows increased numbers of LGBT people in the youngest generation studied (Gen Z) and increasing in all categories in the acronym above all previous generations, and not just in transgender identity. There is no research showing that more trans boys come out than trans girls, despite Shrier\u2019s claim of a \u201csudden spike in transgender identification among teen girls [identifying as boys].\u201d In fact, the data showed the number of young LGBTQ people identifying as lesbian doubled compared to the previous generation, whereas the number of young LGBTQ people identifying as trans went up only by a few points, again disproving the false theory that teen girls are falling prey to a \u201cspike\u201d in gender transition. Gallup researchers: \u201cThe pronounced generational differences raise questions about whether higher LGBT identification in younger than older Americans reflects a true shift in sexual orientation, or if it merely reflects a greater willingness of younger people to identify as LGBT. To the extent it reflects older Americans not wanting to acknowledge an LGBT orientation, the Gallup estimates may underestimate the actual population prevalence of it.\u201d<\/p>\n

\u2014Shrier\u2019s book on what she calls the \u201ctransgender craze\u201d was read and reviewed by medical researcher Dr. Jack Turban, who wrote<\/a>: \u201cThe book’s central (and false) premise is that there are massive numbers of transgender youth who are not truly transgender, but rather just confused, and that they are all being rushed into gender<\/a>-affirming medical interventions and surgeries that they will later regret. As a physician and a researcher who has dedicated my career<\/a> to taking care of and understanding transgender youth, I recognized the book as bizarre and full of misinformation. I assumed it wouldn’t gain much traction. I was wrong.\u201d Turban points out that \u201cShrier did not interview most of the transgender adolescents she wrote about\u2026 only interviewed their parents, who uniformly did not accept their children\u2019s transgender identities. Many of them were estranged from their kids because the children were so hurt by their parents’ rejection. To actually understand the psychology of these young people, one would need to talk to them, not simply rely on stories from parents with whom they do not speak.\u201d<\/p>\n

\t\u2014Claims<\/a> she is being targeted to be \u201ccanceled.\u201d Shrier has appeared at a high-profile Senate hearing, on top-rated podcasts, and she has a platform in The Wall Street Journal, where she continues misrepresenting transgender people, including a column that falsely claimed President Biden\u2019s executive order supporting trans students was \u201cthe end of girls\u2019 sports.\u201d States that include trans girls have a higher rate of girls<\/a> playing sports than states with bans. <\/p>\n

\u2014Described trans rights as a \u201cwar on women<\/a>\u201c and misgendered transgender women as \u201cbiological males who self-identify as females,\u201d falsely claiming trans women\u2019s use of \u201cwomen\u2019s restrooms, locker rooms and protective facilities\u2026 would put women and girls at immediate physical risk.\u201d There is no evidence that letting transgender people use public facilities that align with their gender identity increases safety risks, according to a study<\/a> from the Williams Institute at UCLA School of Law. <\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":435,"featured_media":506173,"template":"","categories":[138754],"tags":[],"region":[138565],"hashtag":[138636,138635],"class_list":{"0":"post-506172","1":"gap","2":"type-gap","3":"status-publish","4":"has-post-thumbnail","6":"category-gaps","7":"region-national","8":"hashtag-anti-transgender","9":"hashtag-commentator"},"aioseo_notices":[],"apple_news_notices":[],"aioseo_head":"\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t